Amigo Brothers: an Argumentative Sample

Amigo Brothers is a short story written by Piri Thomas that revolves around two best friends, Antonio and Felix, who are both passionate about boxing. The story culminates in a boxing match between the two friends to determine who is the better boxer. The question of who truly won the match has sparked debates among readers for years. Some argue that Antonio won the fight, while others believe that Felix emerged victorious. In this essay, I will present arguments supporting the claim that Antonio won the fight based on evidence from the text and logical reasoning.

Antonio's Physical Strength and Skill

Throughout the story, Antonio is portrayed as a skilled and disciplined boxer. He is described as having a powerful punch and excellent footwork, which are essential attributes for a successful boxer. In the opening scene of the story, Antonio is seen training diligently, showing his dedication to the sport. On the other hand, Felix is depicted as a more instinctual and aggressive fighter, relying on his natural talent rather than disciplined training.

During the boxing match, Antonio's physical strength and skill are on full display. He lands several powerful punches on Felix, demonstrating his superior technique and control in the ring. In contrast, Felix's fighting style is described as wild and unstructured, lacking the precision and finesse that Antonio exhibits. This difference in fighting approach gives Antonio an edge over Felix in the match.

The Judges' Decision

Another compelling piece of evidence supporting the argument that Antonio won the fight is the judges' decision at the end of the match. While the story does not explicitly state the judges' verdict, it is implied that Antonio is declared the winner. After the match, both friends are shown to be exhausted and bruised, indicating that it was a close and intense fight. However, Antonio's victory is suggested by the fact that he is the one who gets up first and extends a hand to help Felix, a gesture typically associated with the winner of a boxing match.

Furthermore, the narrative focuses more on Antonio's emotions and thoughts after the match, suggesting that he is the central character and the one who emerges victorious. Felix, on the other hand, is portrayed as accepting his defeat gracefully, further indicating that Antonio was the winner of the match.

Conclusion

In conclusion, based on the evidence presented in the text and logical reasoning, it can be argued that Antonio won the boxing match in Amigo Brothers. His physical strength and skill, as well as the implied judges' decision, support this claim. While Felix is a talented and aggressive fighter, Antonio's disciplined training and technique give him the upper hand in the match. Ultimately, Antonio's victory is not only supported by the text but also aligns with the narrative arc of the story, making him the rightful winner of the match.