Amigo Brothers: an Argumentative Sample

"Amigo Brothers" is a short story by Piri Thomas. It’s about two best friends, Antonio and Felix, who are super into boxing. The story ends with a boxing match between them to see who’s the better boxer. There's been a lot of debate over who actually won the fight. Some folks think Antonio came out on top, while others believe Felix was the winner. In this essay, I’ll argue that Antonio won the fight, using evidence from the story and some logical thinking.

Antonio's Physical Strength and Skill

Antonio is shown as a really skilled and disciplined boxer throughout the story. He’s got a strong punch and great footwork, which are key for a good boxer. Right at the start, we see Antonio training hard, showing how dedicated he is. Felix, on the other hand, is more of a natural and aggressive fighter, relying on his instincts rather than strict training.

During the match, Antonio’s strength and skills are clear. He lands several solid punches on Felix, showing his better technique and control in the ring. Felix’s style is described as wild and unstructured, lacking the precision that Antonio has. This difference in their fighting styles gives Antonio an advantage over Felix in the match.

The Judges' Decision

Another point that supports Antonio winning is the judges' decision at the end. The story doesn’t directly say who won, but it hints that Antonio is the winner. After the match, both friends are tired and bruised, showing it was a tough fight. But Antonio is the one who gets up first and helps Felix, a move usually done by the winner.

Plus, the story focuses more on Antonio’s feelings and thoughts after the match, suggesting he’s the main character and the one who wins. Felix seems to accept his defeat gracefully, which also hints that Antonio was the winner.

Conclusion

So, in conclusion, based on the story and some logical thinking, it seems like Antonio won the boxing match in "Amigo Brothers." His physical strength and skill, along with the implied judges' decision, support this idea. While Felix is a talented and aggressive fighter, Antonio’s disciplined training and technique give him the edge. Antonio’s win isn’t just backed by the story, but it also fits the narrative arc, making him the rightful winner of the match.