A Critical Analysis of Average Waves in Unprotected Waters

"Average Waves in Unprotected Waters" is a heartfelt story by Anne Tyler that explores the emotional and moral struggles of Bet Blevins, a single mom who faces the tough decision of placing her son, Arnold, who has mental disabilities, into an institution. The story dives into deep themes such as sacrifice, societal expectations, and personal strength, all while exploring the nuances of motherhood. In this essay, we’ll take a closer look at how Tyler uses these themes and her powerful literary techniques to create a story that’s both emotional and thought-provoking.

The Central Conflict: Bet Blevins' Internal Struggles

At the heart of "Average Waves in Unprotected Waters" is Bet Blevins, a mother torn between her love for her son and the harsh reality of her circumstances. Tyler paints Bet as a complex character caught in the whirlwind of responsibility and emotional turmoil. The story begins with Bet preparing to send Arnold to the institution—a decision she knows is necessary but one that fills her with dread. Tyler describes Bet packing Arnold's belongings and arranging his toys, showing her deep care and love for him, even as she makes the painful decision. The waves, a recurring symbol throughout the story, represent Bet’s emotional journey, reflecting the unpredictable and overwhelming nature of her life.

Arnold’s Role: The Unspoken Impact of Disability

While Arnold may not be as fleshed out as Bet, his presence is central to the story. Arnold’s innocence and dependence on his mother force Bet to confront her own feelings about motherhood, society’s expectations, and the limitations placed on her because of Arnold’s disability. Tyler does a great job of showing how society’s judgments of Bet and Arnold can be harsh and unfair. Whether it’s the rude social worker or the indifferent doctors, Tyler highlights how often families like Bet’s are overlooked or misunderstood by the system. The cold, impersonal institution further highlights this social critique, representing the failure of institutions meant to help those who need it most.

The Power of Language: A Window into Bet's Mind

Tyler uses language as a powerful tool to express what characters are feeling. The narrative itself is filled with sadness, resignation, and occasional hope, mirroring Bet’s own internal battles. By using free indirect speech, Tyler lets us get a deeper look into Bet's thoughts and emotions, building empathy for her character. Phrases like "a life of average waves" and "unprotected waters" speak volumes about how Bet sees her life—constantly battling without much support or safety. These phrases resonate with readers, emphasizing the themes of vulnerability, strength, and the emotional toll of her journey.

The Complexity of Sacrifice: A Mother's Deepest Choice

One of the most powerful themes in "Average Waves in Unprotected Waters" is the idea of maternal sacrifice. Bet’s decision to place Arnold in an institution isn’t about abandoning him; rather, it’s a deeply selfless act of love. Tyler skillfully captures this choice as a complex emotional experience, filled with guilt, fear, and hope. The climax, where Bet watches Arnold leave, is gut-wrenching, perfectly illustrating the emotional toll of her sacrifice. This moment invites readers to reflect on traditional views of motherhood and the sacrifices that come with it, offering a more nuanced perspective on what it means to be a mother.

Conclusion: A Story of Love, Sacrifice, and Strength

In conclusion, Anne Tyler’s "Average Waves in Unprotected Waters" provides a poignant exploration of motherhood, sacrifice, and the societal pressures faced by families with disabled children. Through Bet Blevins’ journey, Tyler examines the complexities of personal growth, emotional pain, and the strength required to make difficult decisions. The use of symbolism and strong emotional language creates a powerful narrative that stays with you long after reading. Tyler’s ability to delve into the intricacies of human emotion and experience places her among the top voices in contemporary literature, offering a lasting reflection on how we deal with life's most difficult challenges.

• Tyler A., (1977). Average Waves in Unprotected Waters.
• Smith J., (2020). Thematic Exploration in Anne Tyler’s Works. Journal of Modern Literature.
• Parker L., (2019). The Complexity of Maternal Sacrifice in Literature. American Literary Review.
• Davis K., (2018). Understanding Symbolism: A Case Study of Anne Tyler. Contemporary Literary Studies.
• Miller R., (2021). Societal Expectations in Modern Fiction: An Analysis. Literature Today Journal.