An Analysis of Shirley Jackson's "The Possibility of Evil"

Shirley Jackson's short story, "The Possibility of Evil," explores the themes of appearances versus reality and the true nature of evil. Through her vivid characterization, thought-provoking plot, and intricate use of symbolism, Jackson captivates readers and challenges societal perceptions of morality. This essay will delve into these elements to reveal the underlying messages and complexities of Jackson's intriguing narrative.

​

The characters in "The Possibility of Evil" serve as conduits through which Jackson explores the multifaceted nature of humanity. Adela Strangeworth, the story's protagonist, initially appears as a model citizen, admired for her beautiful roses and seemingly kind gestures. However, beneath this facade lies a darker side. Jackson portrays Adela as a symbol of the hypocrisy that can exist within ordinary individuals.

​

Additionally, the townspeople who receive Adela's poison pen letters are not immune to scrutiny. Their reactions highlight the fine line between what society perceives as good and evil. The moral ambiguity of these characters forces readers to question their own preconceived notions of right and wrong. Jackson reminds us that evil can reside in unexpected places, challenging the notion of a clear dichotomy between good and evil.

​

A Plot That Challenges Expectations

The plot of "The Possibility of Evil" takes unexpected turns, keeping readers engrossed and encouraging them to question their assumptions. Initially, the story appears to be a simple exploration of small-town life and the idiosyncrasies of its inhabitants. However, as the narrative progresses, Jackson unveils the disturbing truth behind Adela's seemingly innocent actions.

​

By subverting conventional storytelling techniques, Jackson adds an element of suspense and encourages readers to reflect on their own moral boundaries. The climax of the story, when Adela receives a poison pen letter herself, shakes the foundations of the reader's expectations. Through this unexpected twist, Jackson effectively challenges our understanding of justice and retribution.

Symbols and Their Deeper Meanings

Symbolism permeates "The Possibility of Evil," inviting readers to delve beyond surface-level interpretations and contemplate the darker aspects of human nature. The roses, for instance, represent the juxtaposition of beauty and deceit. The seemingly perfect flowers mask Adela's malevolent actions, forcing readers to ponder the hidden evil that can exist in even the most idyllic settings.

The letters themselves serve as symbols of both the darkness within Adela and the potential evil that lies within each individual. Jackson suggests that just as the letters bring harm, humans possess the capacity for malevolence as well. The allusion to something as mundane as a letter underscores the notion that evil can manifest in ordinary and seemingly innocuous ways.

Conclusion

Shirley Jackson's "The Possibility of Evil" challenges us to confront our own assumptions about good and evil and the often blurred lines between them. Through strategic characterization, an unpredictable plot, and profound symbolism, Jackson implores readers to reflect on the duality of human nature.

This thought-provoking narrative serves as a cautionary tale, reminding us that evil can reside in the most unexpected places and that appearances can be deceiving. By defying traditional storytelling conventions and delving into the depths of the human psyche, Jackson's work forces readers to reconsider their own moral compasses and recognize the potential for darkness within themselves.