Analysis of "Madame Sun Lin Hoo Killed Sam Westing"

In the intriguing mystery novel "The Westing Game" by Ellen Raskin, the question of who killed Sam Westing is at the heart of the story. With a cast of eccentric characters and a complex plot, the novel keeps readers guessing until the very end. This essay will analyze the various clues and evidence provided throughout the book to determine who could have potentially killed Sam Westing. By examining the motives, actions, and relationships of the characters, we can uncover the truth behind this mysterious murder.

1. The first clue that points towards Madame Sun Lin Hoo as a possible suspect is her close proximity to Sam Westing. As a tenant in the Sunset Towers, she has constant access to the victim. Furthermore, Madame Hoo's knowledge of traditional Chinese medicine and her expertise in poisons raises suspicion. In the text, it is mentioned that she has a vast collection of herbs and potions, some of which could potentially be used to commit murder. The fact that she was known to have a strained relationship with Sam Westing adds to the suspicion surrounding her.

2. Another intriguing aspect of Madame Hoo's involvement in Sam Westing's murder is her financial motive. As the owner of a successful restaurant, she stands to gain a significant inheritance if Sam Westing is killed. Madame Hoo has been struggling to keep her business afloat, and the money from the Westing estate could potentially save her from bankruptcy. This financial pressure, coupled with her strained relationship with Sam Westing, creates a strong motive for her to commit the crime.

3. In addition to motive and opportunity, Madame Hoo's actions throughout the novel also raise suspicion. She is often seen sneaking around the Sunset Towers, eavesdropping on conversations and gathering information. This suggests a level of involvement in the mystery that goes beyond mere curiosity. Furthermore, her knowledge of Sam Westing's past and her ability to navigate the complex clues left behind indicate that she may have had insider knowledge of the murder.

4. However, it is important to consider other potential suspects in the murder of Sam Westing. Angela Wexler, for example, stands out as another possible culprit. As Sam Westing's niece, she has a strong motive to kill him in order to inherit his wealth. Angela's seemingly innocent and naive demeanor could be a façade to divert suspicion away from her. Additionally, her close relationship with Turtle Wexler, a cunning and resourceful character, could suggest a joint effort between the two.

In conclusion, the question of who killed Sam Westing is a central mystery in Ellen Raskin's "The Westing Game." While Madame Sun Lin Hoo emerges as a strong suspect due to her proximity, motive, and actions, it is important to consider other potential suspects as well. Angela Wexler, with her familial ties and close relationship with Turtle Wexler, cannot be dismissed as a potential culprit. Ultimately, it is up to the reader to analyze the evidence and make their own conclusions about who killed Sam Westing. The novel's complex characters and intricate plot make for an engaging and thought-provoking reading experience, leaving readers with a sense of intrigue and the desire to delve deeper into the mystery.