Comparsion of Freire’s Pedagogy of The Oppressed and Rousseau’s Natural Education

Introduction

The realm of education is a canvas on which diverse philosophies and ideologies are painted. Two prominent figures in this vast landscape are Paulo Freire and Jean-Jacques Rousseau. Freire, born in poverty-stricken Brazil, emerged as a revolutionary pedagogue with his "banking concept of education", while Rousseau, an 18th-century philosopher, laid the foundations for a child-centered, natural approach to education. This essay delves into the distinctive philosophies of these educators and explores their implications in contemporary educational discourse.

Paulo Freire: Pedagogy of the Oppressed

Paulo Freire, a product of a humble background, was deeply affected by the poverty and hunger he witnessed during the Great Depression. These early experiences ignited his passion for improving the lives of the marginalized. Freire identified a profound link between social class and knowledge acquisition, which ultimately led him to dedicate his life to the field of education. He believed that the educational system played a pivotal role in perpetuating oppression and, thus, advocated for its transformation.

Central to Freire's philosophy is his critique of what he termed the "banking concept of education." In this traditional model, teachers deposit knowledge into the minds of passive students, treating them as empty vessels. This approach, Freire argued, transformed students into mere recipients of information, reinforcing existing power structures. He advocated for a student-centered approach that challenges the traditional transmission of facts. Problem-posing education, as proposed by Freire, transforms the teacher-student dynamic into a collaborative endeavor where both parties engage as co-investigators of knowledge. This method, rooted in critical thinking and action, empowers students to shape their own learning experiences.

Summary  of the Key Features of Freire's Philosophy:

1. Critique of the Banking Concept: At the heart of Freire's philosophy is his scathing critique of the traditional "banking concept of education." In this model, teachers deposit knowledge into passive students, treating them as empty receptacles. This approach, Freire argued, perpetuates existing power imbalances and stifles critical thinking.
2. Problem-Posing Education: Freire championed problem-posing education, where teachers and students engage as co-investigators of knowledge. This collaborative approach encourages critical thinking, dialogue, and action. It empowers students to shape their own learning experiences, fostering autonomy and agency.
3. Social Transformation: Freire believed that education played a central role in maintaining oppression. Therefore, he advocated for the transformation of the educational system to challenge and ultimately dismantle oppressive structures. Education, in his view, was a catalyst for social change.
4. Empowerment: Central to Freire's philosophy is the concept of empowerment. He saw education as a tool for marginalized individuals to critically analyze their reality, understand their oppression, and take action to change it. Empowerment through education was the path to liberation.
5. Liberation and Social Justice: Freire's ultimate goal was the liberation of the oppressed. He envisioned a just society where individuals had the opportunity to lead dignified lives, free from the shackles of poverty and oppression.

Jean-Jacques Rousseau: Natural Education

Jean-Jacques Rousseau, an 18th-century philosopher, introduced the concept of natural education, emphasizing the importance of nurturing a child's innate potential. Rousseau believed that if children were shielded from societal pressures and influences, they could naturally develop to their fullest potential, both educationally and morally. His groundbreaking work, "Emile," published in 1762, laid the groundwork for a child-centered approach to education.

Rousseau's theory of human development posited that all humans undergo a common developmental process driven by their innate nature. Unlike John Locke's tabula rasa, which implies a blank slate awaiting external influences, Rousseau believed that children actively engage with their surroundings, leading to their growth and learning. He advocated for an education system that aligns with the child's needs and experiences at each stage of development. This child-centered philosophy emphasized hands-on, sensory-driven, practical experiences that allow children to adapt and learn from their environment.

According to Rousseau, education should respect the child's natural developmental trajectory and be focused on the child's experiences, rather than imposing external ideas or influences. The curriculum should emerge organically from the needs and interests of the child. Rousseau's approach envisions children as active learners who gain knowledge through experiences and imitation, requiring guidance at different stages of their lives.

Summary of the Key Features of Rousseau's Philosophy:

1. Innate Goodness: Rousseau believed that children were born inherently good and that their natural development should be nurtured rather than constrained by societal influences. He advocated for a form of education that respected and preserved this inherent goodness.
2. Child-Centered Education: Central to Rousseau's philosophy is the concept of child-centered education. He emphasized that education should align with the child's developmental needs and experiences at each stage of growth. This approach values hands-on, sensory-driven, and practical experiences.
3. Freedom from Society: Rousseau's theory encouraged protecting children from societal pressures and influences, allowing them to develop naturally. He believed that societal corruption hindered a child's moral and intellectual growth.
4. Active Learning: Rousseau's philosophy promoted active learning, where children learn by engaging with their environment. Practical experiences, such as play, sports, and hands-on activities, were considered crucial for physical and intellectual development.
5. Age-Appropriate Guidance: While Rousseau advocated for freedom in education, he also recognized the need for age-appropriate guidance. Educators and parents should provide support and structure based on the child's stage of development.

Conclusion

In the realm of education, the philosophies of Paulo Freire and Jean-Jacques Rousseau offer distinct perspectives on how learners acquire knowledge and engage with the world. Freire's pedagogy of the oppressed challenges the traditional teacher-centered approach, advocating for critical thinking and collaborative learning. In contrast, Rousseau's natural education emphasizes the importance of nurturing a child's innate potential through hands-on, experiential learning.

Both philosophies continue to influence modern educational discourse. Freire's emphasis on student-centered, problem-posing education resonates with contemporary calls for active learning and critical thinking. Rousseau's child-centered approach aligns with current trends in early childhood education, emphasizing experiential learning and the child's developmental needs.

In essence, the philosophies of Freire and Rousseau highlight the importance of respecting the learner's agency and developmental journey. While their approaches may differ in some aspects, they share a common goal: to empower learners to actively engage with their education and the world around them.

References

1. Aijssnet.com. (2019). [online] Available at: https://www.aijssnet.com/journals/Vol_2_No_2_March_2013/3.pdf [Accessed 10 Oct. 2019].
2. Cavehill.uwi.edu. (2019). [online] Available at: https://www.cavehill.uwi.edu/fhe/histphil/chips/archives/2008/docs/rocha2008.aspx [Accessed 10 Oct. 2019].
3. Glavin, C. (2018, September 26). Paulo Reglus Neves Freire. Retrieved from https://www.k12academics.com/educational-philosophy/paulo-freire
4. Infed.org. (2019). Jean-Jacques Rousseau on nature, wholeness and education | infed.org. [online] Available at: http://infed.org/mobi/jean-jacques-rousseau-on-nature-wholeness-and-education/ [Accessed 10 Oct. 2019].
5. K12academics.com. (2019). Jean-Jacques Rousseau | K12 Academics. [online] Available at: https://www.k12academics.com/educational-philosophy/rousseau [Accessed 10 Oct. 2019].
6. Paulo Freire (1921–1997) - Conceptual Tools, Philosophy of Education, Criticism. (n.d.). Retrieved from https://education.stateuniversity.com/pages/1998/Freire-Paulo-1921-1997.html