The Theme of Deception in "The Taming of The Shrew"

In Shakespeare's comedic masterpiece, The Taming of the Shrew, the theme of deception weaves a complex tapestry, as characters don various disguises that conceal and, ultimately, reveal their true selves. This pervasive theme of deception showcases Shakespeare's skill in using both psychological and physical disguises to illuminate the essence of his characters.

Bianca's Mask of Innocence

Bianca, the seemingly innocent daughter, cleverly conceals her true temperament beneath a facade of sweetness. Her father, blinded by favoritism, perceives her as a "poor girl" who weeps, projecting an image of her as "fair and virtuous." This portrayal of Bianca suggests a young woman embodying innocence and beauty, a victim of her sister Katherina's cruelty. However, beneath the surface, Bianca's character unfolds gradually throughout the play. She boldly asserts, "I learn my lessons as I please myself," hinting at a more assertive persona lurking within. This statement reveals her privilege and contradicts the fabricated innocence she presents. Finally, near the play's conclusion, Bianca sheds her facade with the declaration, "the more fool you for laying on my duty." This moment exposes her as a strong, self-assured woman, challenging societal norms of her time. Bianca adeptly concealed her true self for a substantial period, while other characters resorted to physical disguises, which proved less convincing in maintaining their deception.

The Fragile Guises of Lucentio and Hortensio

Lucentio and Hortensio, smitten with Bianca, endeavor to win her love by adopting the personas of schoolmasters. Their disguises quickly unravel, revealing their authentic characters. Lucentio, blinded by infatuation, becomes "Cambio," a schoolteacher tasked with instructing Bianca. However, his vulnerability becomes evident as he confides in Bianca about his true intentions. He promptly unveils his real identity, showcasing his youthful naivety and impulsiveness. His frustration at Bianca's wilfulness exposes his unreadiness for marriage. The two schoolmasters, Lucentio and Hortensio, struggle to maintain their deceptive roles as teachers, suggesting their true selves were more favorable than the disguises they donned.

The Pedant's Vulnerable Facade

The Pedant, forced to impersonate Lucentio's father, ultimately faces exposure. Fearful for his life, he is manipulated by Tranio, who convinces him to assume this role. However, beneath Tranio's courteous demeanor lies a selfish agenda. The Pedant's willingness to cooperate underscores Shakespeare's portrayal of deception as a multifaceted endeavor. This plan is volatile, relying on the assumption that the Pedant remains unaware of contradictory information. Shakespeare cautions against trust based solely on appearances, highlighting that many harbor hidden motives. The Pedant's knowledge of Baptista, whom he had met previously and now deceives, further underscores this cautionary tale, suggesting that even individuals one has trusted may not be as honest as they seem.

Consequences of Concealment

Irrefutably, the characters' facades were exposed; it simply proved too difficult to uphold these artificialities over such a period of time. The characters in The Taming of the Shrew all hid themselves through disguises under which they increasingly revealed more about themselves, demonstrating that individuals' personalities will eventually be discovered. Bianca displayed her true disposition, which severely contrasted with the beliefs about her innocence and beauty, whilst the physical disguises which Lucentio and Hortensio adopted were much less effective. The two schoolmasters discovered more about themselves and showed such new insights to the reader, while the merchant disguised under duress depicted his focus on self-preservation. All of the characters' qualities were made apparent to the readers as Shakespeare implicitly exhibited his own attitudes.

Bianca, the younger daughter of Baptista, serves as an interesting focal point in the exploration of deception within the play. Her character is marked by a stark contrast between her public image and her concealed true self. Initially, she is portrayed as the embodiment of innocence and beauty, a helpless victim of her older sister Katherina's scolding. Her father Baptista, in particular, sympathizes with her, lamenting, "poor girl, she weeps," reinforcing the idea that she is a gentle soul unjustly subjected to Katherina's wrath. This perception of Bianca as "fair and virtuous" constructs an image of her as the ideal daughter, an image that conveniently aligns with her father's preferences.

However, beneath this carefully constructed facade, Bianca's character gradually develops throughout the play. She boldly asserts her autonomy, proclaiming, "I learn my lessons as I please myself." This assertion challenges the submissive image associated with her character, revealing her independence and determination to assert her own will. The use of the phrase "as I please myself" suggests a level of privilege and self-assuredness inconsistent with the fabricated innocence she presents to her father and suitors.

Bianca's true self is further unveiled as she rebukes her suitors near the play's conclusion, declaring, "the more fool you for laying on my duty." This moment marks a significant departure from her earlier persona as the docile and obedient daughter. Instead, she asserts herself as a strong, self-assured woman who refuses to conform to societal expectations. By challenging her suitors and asserting her own desires, Bianca shatters the illusion of innocence that she had carefully maintained throughout the play.

While Bianca's transformation is gradual and subtle, it serves as a powerful example of how characters in the play use deception to obscure their true selves. Her ability to convincingly conceal her authentic disposition for an extended period of time contrasts with the physical disguises adopted by other characters, which prove less effective in concealing their true natures.

Lucentio, one of Bianca's suitors, attempts to win her love by adopting the persona of "Cambio," a schoolteacher tasked with instructing her. His infatuation with Bianca leads him to resort to this disguise as a means to be close to her. However, the vulnerability of his deception becomes evident when he confides in Bianca about his true intentions. He admits, "I am content to be Lucentio, / Because so well I love Lucentio." In this moment of vulnerability, Lucentio unveils his true identity, acknowledging that his desire for Bianca compels him to reveal the truth. This confession exposes his youthful naivety and impulsive nature, as he readily abandons his disguise to win her affection.

Similarly, Hortensio, another suitor, assumes the role of a schoolmaster named "Licio" in an attempt to court Bianca. However, he quickly realizes the futility of his disguise as he witnesses Bianca's wilfulness and disobedience. He confesses, "Tut, she's a lamb, a dove, a fool to him!" In this statement, Hortensio reveals his true feelings about Bianca and his frustration with her behaviour. The effectiveness of his disguise diminishes as he abandons the pretense of being a schoolmaster and confesses his true intentions to marry her. Hortensio's willingness to drop his disguise suggests that his genuine self is more favorable than the false identity he had assumed.

The experiences of Lucentio and Hortensio illustrate the limitations of physical disguises in concealing one's true character. While they initially adopt these disguises to pursue Bianca, their respective vulnerabilities and true feelings are ultimately exposed. In contrast, Bianca's use of psychological deception allows her to maintain her facade for an extended period, making her transformation all the more striking.

The character known as the Pedant provides another perspective on deception within the play. Forced to impersonate Vincentio, Lucentio's father, the Pedant finds himself entangled in a web of deceit. Fearful for his life, he is manipulated by Tranio, who convinces him to assume this role. However, beneath Tranio's courteous demeanor lies a selfish agenda. The Pedant's willingness to cooperate underscores Shakespeare's portrayal of deception as a multifaceted endeavor.

Tranio persuades the Pedant by emphasizing the importance of their shared deception, asserting, "Sir, I must have had you a better father / Than that, if I had paid it." This statement subtly implies that the Pedant owes him a debt of gratitude for sparing him from a potentially worse fate. Tranio presents his actions as a favor, masking his true motives behind a facade of helpfulness.

Furthermore, Tranio's manipulation of the Pedant involves appealing to his sense of duty and honor. He states, "I knew the man, and have heard him say / No less of her than I have often heard." In this way, Tranio attempts to convince the Pedant that he is acting in service of Vincentio's wishes. He frames their actions as aligning with the genuine desires of the man they are impersonating, thereby justifying their deception.

This plan is volatile, relying on the assumption that the Pedant remains unaware of contradictory information. Shakespeare cautions against trust based solely on appearances, highlighting that many harbor hidden motives. The Pedant's knowledge of Baptista, whom he had met previously and now deceives, further underscores this cautionary tale, suggesting that even individuals one has trusted may not be as honest as they seem.

Conclusion

Ultimately, the characters' facades crumble under the weight of time and the intricacies of their deceptions. Bianca's transformation from a seemingly innocent daughter to a strong, self-assured woman challenges societal expectations. Lucentio and Hortensio, despite their attempts to court Bianca through disguise, reveal their true selves as impulsive and frustrated suitors. The Pedant's vulnerability underlines the multifaceted nature of deception, as individuals may resort to manipulation and coercion to maintain their facades.

Shakespeare's exploration of deception in The Taming of the Shrew serves as a compelling commentary on human nature and the consequences of concealing one's true self. While characters like Bianca skillfully employ psychological deception to maintain their illusions, others find their physical disguises unraveling, exposing their vulnerabilities and authentic feelings. The play reminds us that, in the end, true character will always emerge from behind the masks we wear.

References

1. Shakespeare, W. (1992). The Taming of the Shrew (A. R. Braunmuller, Ed.). Oxford University Press.
2. Callaghan, D. (2006). Shakespeare's Sonnets. Wiley.
3. Mowat, B. A., & Werstine, P. (Eds.). (2006). The Taming of the Shrew (Folger Shakespeare Library). Washington Square Press.
4. Gibbons, B. J. (1980). The Taming of the Shrew: Shakespeare's Mirror of Marriage. Shakespeare Quarterly, 31(1), 53-69.
5. Smith, D. F. (2005). Reading the third time: Shakespeare, literary theory, and the discipline of English. University of Wisconsin Press.
6. Barton, A. (1991). Playing and reality: The mode of illusion in the Renaissance. Theatre Journal, 43(3), 327-337.
7. Bergeron, D. M. (2016). Introduction: What is a shrew? In A Cultural History of Shrews in the Medieval Age and Beyond (pp. 1-13). Palgrave Macmillan.