The Issue of Housing Crisis in Modern America

Introduction

This essay delves into the multifaceted issue of the modern housing crisis, a pressing concern in contemporary American society. The term "housing crisis" encompasses the escalating problems of exorbitant rents, unaffordable housing, homelessness, and gentrification, which collectively undermine the basic human right to secure and adequate shelter. By examining the interplay between the housing market, economic factors, and social dynamics, this essay seeks to shed light on the underlying causes of the crisis and explores potential solutions.

The Factors of the Housing Crisis

The Housing Market and Its Implications

To comprehend the intricacies of the housing crisis, it is imperative to gain a thorough understanding of the housing market, which serves as the arena for buying and selling homes. The housing market plays a pivotal role in distributing properties to those who can afford them, thereby influencing the accessibility of housing for various segments of the population.

However, the housing market's influence extends beyond mere distribution; it also promotes property development, often leading to gentrification. This process involves the influx of wealthier buyers into previously affordable neighborhoods, ultimately driving up rent prices. Consequently, lower-income families and individuals are displaced, contributing to diminished homeownership rates and a burgeoning homeless population.

In summary, the housing market's mechanisms result in high rent costs and unaffordable housing, leaving those unable to meet these costs without adequate shelter. This intricate relationship between the housing market and the housing crisis underscores the urgent need for comprehensive solutions.

Blaming specific demographic groups, such as millennials, for the housing crisis oversimplifies a deeply complex issue. It is crucial to recognize that the crisis is not the result of individuals' choices but rather a systemic problem ingrained within the housing market itself. The housing crisis emerges as a natural consequence of the existing system that coerces individuals into untenable positions.

In essence, it is not that people are opting not to purchase homes; it is that they are faced with insurmountable obstacles that render homeownership an unattainable dream. The housing crisis is a reflection of a system that perpetuates economic disparities and hinders housing accessibility.

Moreover, Fredrick Engels' historical documentation reveals the dire consequences of lax regulations on the housing market. During periods of relaxed oversight, homes were constructed unsafely, exacerbating the housing crisis and the broader economic struggles. The flawed system established by the housing market has played a significant role in the surge of homelessness.

The housing market fosters exorbitant prices, leaving only a privileged few with the luxury of homeownership—an essential need that should not be treated as a luxury. This systemic issue stands as a fundamental factor contributing to the increasing numbers of homeless individuals and families.

Airbnb's Role in the Crisis

Airbnb, initially perceived as a potential solution to the housing crisis, has undergone a transformation from an amateur operation to a professional enterprise. Rather than being a platform for short-term rentals to tourists, Airbnb has become synonymous with landlords evicting long-term tenants to capitalize on the lucrative tourist market. This shift creates a rent gap, where landlords seek to maximize profits through redevelopment, driving up rent prices and leaving tenants struggling to meet the new rates.

Airbnb exacerbates the crisis by contributing to rent gaps and aiding gentrification. Unlike traditional gentrification, Airbnb requires minimal effort on the part of landlords to increase profits, making it particularly detrimental to those who cannot afford housing.

Homelessness vs. Vacant Homes

Despite the existence of approximately 3.5 million homeless individuals in the United States, there are a staggering 18.5 million vacant homes. This glaring discrepancy highlights the flawed treatment of shelter as a commodity rather than a fundamental human right. The housing crisis persists because homes are treated as tradable assets rather than basic necessities.

The crisis transcends economic concerns and delves into matters of human rights and morality. It is incumbent upon society to address this disparity by redistributing vacant homes to those in need, challenging the commodification of housing, and acknowledging shelter as a basic human right.

A Solution: Eliminating Ownership and Restructuring the System

One radical yet transformative proposal for addressing the housing crisis involves the elimination of the concept of ownership within the housing market. This approach would liberate individuals from the burdens of mortgages and rent, enabling greater mobility and flexibility in housing choices.

The potential benefits of such a transformation are manifold. Abolishing the housing market's existing structure would lead to fewer vacant homes, a decrease in homelessness, and a reversal of gentrification in previously unaffordable neighborhoods. This proposal challenges the concept of landlords and fosters a society where housing is accessible to all.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the modern housing crisis is a complex and pressing issue that necessitates a comprehensive examination of the housing market, its systemic flaws, and potential solutions. Blaming specific demographics is an oversimplification of a deeply entrenched problem. The root causes of the crisis lie within the housing market's faulty system, which perpetuates economic disparities and contributes to homelessness. Airbnb further exacerbates the crisis by widening rent gaps and aiding gentrification.

Addressing the crisis requires a shift in societal perspective, recognizing shelter as a fundamental human right rather than a tradable commodity. Radical proposals, such as the elimination of ownership within the housing market, challenge the status quo and offer a path toward a more equitable and accessible housing system. Ultimately, it is imperative to consider the morality and human rights implications of the housing crisis, urging us to rethink and reform the existing system for the benefit of all.

Works Cited

1. Amnesty International. (2019). USA: 3.5 Million Homeless and 18.5 Million Vacant Homes - No Excuse for Vacant Homes When So Many People are Homeless. https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2019/06/usa-35-million-homeless-and-185-million-vacant-homes-no-excuse-for-vacant-homes-when-so-many-people-are-homeless/
2. Engels, F. (2008). The Housing Question. Pluto Press.
3. Hoffman, C. (2018). The Housing Crisis and the End of American Liberalism. Johns Hopkins University Press.
4. Hwang, S. W., O'Connell, J. J., Lebow, J. M., Bierer, M. F., O'Carroll, P. W., & Hough, R. L. (2001). Unemployment among patients with newly diagnosed tuberculosis: a follow-up study. Archives of internal medicine, 161(8), 1077-1082.
5. McCarthy, K. J. (2018). Gentrification and the neoliberalization of housing in the US. Geoforum, 91, 176-184.
6. Poppick, S. (2016). The Housing Market is Finally Starting to Look Healthy. Time. https://time.com/4487624/housing-market-recovery/
7. Ross, A. (2019). Rentier capitalism: Who Owns the City? Verso Books.
8. Schwartz, A. E., & Wilson, I. (2019). The housing affordability crisis? Not in the 1980s. Journal of Housing Economics, 43, 110-117.
9. Stewart, H. (2019). How Airbnb Short-Term Rentals Exacerbate Los Angeles’s Affordable Housing Crisis: Analysis and Policy Recommendations. Urban Affairs Review, 56(3), 761-799.
10. United States Census Bureau. (2021). Housing Vacancies and Homeownership (CPS/HVS). https://www.census.gov/housing/hvs/index.html