Moral Dilemmas in "What of This Goldfish, Would You Wish?"

Short stories have the unique ability to encapsulate profound moral dilemmas within a compact narrative. "What of This Goldfish, Would You Wish?" by Etgar Keret is one such tale that delves deep into the complexities of human ethics. This essay embarks on a comprehensive exploration of the moral dilemmas presented in the story, shedding light on the choices made by its characters and the broader implications for society.

The Ethical Conundrum: Granting Wishes

The central ethical dilemma in the story revolves around the magical goldfish, who has the power to grant three wishes to anyone who captures it. The protagonist, Sergei Goralick, stumbles upon the goldfish and must make a series of moral decisions. The wishes he seeks force him to confront his values, desires, and the consequences of his actions.

One of the most significant moral questions raised by the story is whether individuals should possess the power to alter their fates through wishes. This question delves into the very heart of human nature—our desires for a better life, our willingness to change the course of events, and our understanding of the potential consequences.

The Wishes and Their Implications

Sergei's first wish—to have peace and quiet—may seem innocent on the surface, but it leads to the death of his beloved goldfish. This wish reflects the human tendency to seek comfort and escape from life's chaos, even if it means sacrificing something precious. It raises questions about the cost of personal peace and whether it can be achieved at the expense of others.

His second wish—to have the goldfish back, alive and well—raises ethical questions about the power dynamics between humans and nature. Sergei wishes for the reversal of a death he caused, questioning whether humans should have the authority to undo their actions when they result in harm to the natural world.

Finally, Sergei's third wish—to know what the goldfish wished for—is a profound reflection on empathy and understanding. It highlights the importance of considering the perspectives and desires of others, even those we might perceive as insignificant or different from ourselves. This wish underscores the need for compassion and the recognition that all beings have their own wishes and desires.

The Broader Implications

"What of This Goldfish, Would You Wish?" extends beyond Sergei's personal dilemmas and resonates with broader societal questions. It prompts readers to contemplate the ethical implications of power and choice, both on an individual and societal level.

The story challenges us to reflect on our own wishes and desires, urging us to consider the consequences of our actions on the world around us. It underscores the importance of responsible decision-making and the moral responsibility we bear for our choices.

Conclusion: The Layers of Ethical Complexity

Etgar Keret's "What of This Goldfish, Would You Wish?" masterfully weaves a tale of moral complexity and ethical quandaries. Through Sergei's journey, we are compelled to examine our own values, desires, and the consequences of our actions.

The story serves as a powerful reminder that ethical dilemmas are not confined to the pages of fiction but are integral to the human experience. It challenges us to confront the moral choices we make in our own lives and the profound impact they can have on the world around us.