Patriotism, Realism, and Moral Dilemmas in William Dean Howells' "Editha"

Introduction

William Dean Howells, a prominent figure in American literary realism, is known for his keen social observations and critique of romantic ideals. His short story "Editha," first published in 1905, is an incisive exploration of patriotism, war, and moral dilemmas through the lens of its titular character. The narrative delves into the complexities of human nature, highlighting the often-blurred line between idealism and reality. This essay aims to analyze the central themes and characters of "Editha," examining how Howells uses irony, symbolism, and characterization to convey his critique of romanticized patriotism and to underscore the harsh realities of war.

Body Paragraph

"Editha" centers around the protagonist Editha Balcom, a young woman whose fervent patriotism and romanticized notions of war drive the story's conflict. Her character embodies the idealistic and often naive attitudes towards war that were prevalent during the period. Editha's enthusiasm for the Spanish-American War is evident when she persuades her fiancé, George Gearson, to enlist. She views war as a noble endeavor, a chance for George to prove his manhood and patriotism. This perspective is encapsulated in her statement, "But don't you see, dearest, that it wouldn't have come to this if it hadn't been in the order of Providence?" Editha's conviction that the war is divinely sanctioned reflects her uncritical acceptance of societal and cultural narratives surrounding patriotism and heroism.

Howells employs irony throughout the story to critique Editha's romanticized view of war. This is particularly evident in George's reluctance and eventual capitulation to Editha's pressure. Unlike Editha, George possesses a more nuanced and realistic understanding of war. He recognizes its brutality and the moral complexities involved, stating, "I never thought I should have to kill a man." George's internal conflict and eventual decision to enlist highlight the tension between personal convictions and societal expectations. His tragic fate—dying in his first battle—serves as a stark contrast to Editha's glorified vision of war and underscores the devastating consequences of blind patriotism.

Symbolism also plays a critical role in "Editha." The yellow ribbon that Editha gives George symbolizes her superficial and misguided beliefs about war. It represents her desire to mold George into her ideal of a war hero, disregarding his true feelings and the potential consequences. The ribbon, vibrant and cheerful in color, starkly contrasts with the grim reality of war, further emphasizing the disconnect between Editha's fantasies and the actual horrors faced by soldiers. Additionally, the letter Editha writes to George, which he carries with him to the battlefield, symbolizes the weight of societal and romantic expectations placed upon individuals, often leading them to act against their better judgment.

Editha's interaction with George's mother after his death serves as a pivotal moment in the story, revealing the profound impact of her actions. Mrs. Gearson's grief and anger expose the human cost of war and challenge Editha's justifications. She bluntly tells Editha, "I thank my God he didn't live to do it!" This confrontation forces Editha to confront the reality of her influence and the consequences of her romanticized beliefs. However, her refusal to acknowledge her culpability and her retreat into further denial illustrate the persistent danger of unexamined ideals. Editha's character remains largely unchanged, suggesting Howells' critique of societal tendencies to cling to comforting illusions rather than face uncomfortable truths.

Conclusion

In "Editha," William Dean Howells masterfully critiques the romanticization of war and patriotism through a combination of irony, symbolism, and nuanced characterization. By juxtaposing Editha's idealism with the grim realities faced by George and his mother, Howells exposes the moral and emotional complexities of war. The story serves as a timeless reminder of the dangers of blind patriotism and the importance of critical reflection on societal values. Through Editha's journey, Howells encourages readers to question the narratives they are presented with and to recognize the often harsh and unglamorous truths that lie beneath the surface of romanticized ideals.

Ultimately, "Editha" stands as a powerful exploration of the human condition, challenging readers to consider the implications of their beliefs and actions. Howells' portrayal of Editha's unwavering idealism and its tragic consequences serves as a cautionary tale, urging a more thoughtful and realistic approach to understanding and engaging with the world.