Should Columbus Day Be Abolished?

Columbus Day has been a federal holiday in the United States since 1937, celebrating the arrival of Christopher Columbus in the Americas. However, the celebration of Columbus Day has become increasingly controversial in recent years, with many arguing that it should be abolished. This essay will explore the reasons why Columbus Day should be abolished, including the negative impact of Columbus's arrival on indigenous populations, the historical inaccuracy of celebrating Columbus as a hero, and the need to recognize and celebrate the contributions of indigenous peoples.

Negative Impact on Indigenous Populations

One of the primary reasons why Columbus Day should be abolished is the negative impact of Columbus's arrival on indigenous populations. When Columbus arrived in the Americas in 1492, he initiated a period of colonization and exploitation that led to the decimation of indigenous populations through violence, disease, and forced labor. According to historian Howard Zinn, the arrival of Columbus marked the beginning of a long history of oppression and marginalization of indigenous peoples in the Americas. Celebrating Columbus Day ignores this history of violence and injustice, and perpetuates a narrative that erases the experiences of indigenous peoples.

Historical Inaccuracy

Another reason to abolish Columbus Day is the historical inaccuracy of celebrating Columbus as a hero. While Columbus is often portrayed as a brave explorer who discovered the Americas, this narrative ignores the fact that indigenous peoples had been living in the Americas for thousands of years before Columbus's arrival. Additionally, Columbus's arrival did not lead to the discovery of the Americas, as there were already thriving civilizations in the region. By celebrating Columbus Day, we perpetuate a myth that erases the contributions and experiences of indigenous peoples, and perpetuates a Eurocentric view of history.

Recognition of Indigenous Contributions

Abolishing Columbus Day is also important for recognizing and celebrating the contributions of indigenous peoples. Indigenous cultures and civilizations have a rich history and heritage that deserves to be acknowledged and celebrated. By abolishing Columbus Day, we can create space for a holiday that honors and recognizes the resilience, strength, and contributions of indigenous peoples. This can help to elevate indigenous voices and experiences, and create a more inclusive and accurate understanding of history.

Conclusion

Columbus Day should be abolished due to the negative impact of Columbus's arrival on indigenous populations, the historical inaccuracy of celebrating Columbus as a hero, and the need to recognize and celebrate the contributions of indigenous peoples. By abolishing Columbus Day, we can take a step towards acknowledging and addressing the injustices of the past, and create space for a more inclusive and accurate understanding of history. It is time to reevaluate the celebration of Columbus Day and consider alternative ways to honor and recognize the diverse histories and experiences of the Americas.