The Great Depression: Hoover's and Roosevelt's Approaches

About this sample

About this sample

Essay grade:
arrow downward Read Review

4 pages /

1770 words

Downloads: 228

4 pages /

1770 words

Downloads: 228

downloadDownload printPrint
Essay grade:
arrow downward Read Review

The Great Depression lasted from 1929 to 1940 and was the most exceedingly bad financial downturn in the historical backdrop of the industrialized world. It started after the stock market crash of October 1929, which sent Wall Street into frenzy and wiped out a huge number of financial specialists and investors. For many years afterward, shopper spending and venture dropped, causing steep decreases in modern yield and work as coming up short organizations laid off laborers.

'Why Violent Video Games Shouldn't Be Banned'?

By 1933, when the Great Depression reached its maximum point, somewhere in the range of 15 million Americans were jobless and about a large portion of the nation's banks had gone out of business. Although former president Hoover tried to help the people by advocating self-reliance, President Roosevelt put in place economic policies such as the New Deal, public initiative programs for farmers, and his own personal philosophies that were much more effective than President Hoover’s.

In his 1932 run for the administration, Roosevelt declared that he would help "the overlooked man at the base of the monetary pyramid," and swore himself to "another arrangement for the American individuals." In his First Inaugural Address, saying "the only thing we have to fear is fear itself," he tried to console people in general in the midst of the nerves of the Great Depression. As president, he championed the arrangement of government authoritative activities known as the New Deal. The New Deal was not a diagram for activity, but instead was rather enlivened by a soul, as Roosevelt stated, of "intense, constant experimentation," in which he would "take a technique and attempt it: if it fizzles, let it out honestly and attempt another."

The Great Depression of the 1930s declined the already grim financial circumstance of African Americans. They were the first to be laid off from their occupations, and they experienced an unemployment rate a few times that of whites. In early open help programs, African Americans frequently got considerably less guide than whites, and some beneficent associations even barred blacks from their soup kitchens. From A People’s History of the United States, Howard Zinn states, “For black people, the New Deal was psychologically encouraging” (Doc 6). Although the New Deal did not solve every problem, it was an improvement. Until the New Deal, blacks had demonstrated their conventional unwavering to the gathering of Abraham Lincoln by voting overwhelmingly Republican. Before the finish of Roosevelt's first organization, nonetheless, a standout amongst the most significant voter moves in American history had happened. In 1936, exactly 75 percent of black voters bolstered the Democrats.

Blacks swung to Roosevelt, to a limited extent, since his spending programs gave them a measure of alleviation from the Depression and, to a limited extent, on the grounds that the GOP had done little to reimburse their prior help. Roosevelt named Mary McLeod Bethune, a dark instructor, to the warning board of trustees of the National Youth Administration (NYA). Because of her endeavors, blacks got a decent amount of NYA reserves. The WPA was partially blind, and blacks in northern urban areas profited from its work help programs. Harold Ickes, a solid supporter of social liberties who had a few blacks on his staff, emptied government stores into dark schools and healing centers in the South.

Women in proficient professions lost progress made in prior, steadier periods. Less women discovered positions in business in the Great Depression than in the 1920s. Losing ground in the conventional male circle, a few men additionally went into occupations up until now consigned to ladies. This pattern happened even in the exceptionally female bastion of instructing. The showing calling became somewhat less female amid the Great Depression; women had constituted 85 percent of instructors in 1920, yet by 1940 they constituted just 78 percent. David M. Kennedy from the Oxford University Press said, “Working women at first lost their jobs at a faster rate than men- then re-entered the workforce more rapidly” (Doc 5).

Role changes turned into the standard for women adapting to and adjusting to the financial changes expedited by the Great Depression. Men were radically expelled from the position of provider, and numerous ladies were pushed into the position of working outside of the home. Out of the blue, a noteworthy number of ladies made up around 25% of the workforce. Spots of work for ladies included eateries, production lines, laundries and excellence shops. A few women filled in as instructors, secretaries, bookkeepers and medical attendants. Thus the Great Depression, however a monetary emergency, filled in as an open door for minority groups to build their essence in the workforce. Farmers too suffered a lot during this time period.

The Great Depression changed the lives of individuals who lived and cultivated on the Great Plains and thus, changed America. The administration programs that helped them to survive the 1930s changed the eventual fate of farming. Climate touched all aspects of life in the "Messy 30s": tidy, creepy crawlies, summer warmth and winter cool. York County farming families didn't have warmth, light or indoor lavatories like individuals who lived in the local area. Many ranch families raised the greater part of their own nourishment – eggs and chickens, drain and meat from their own particular dairy animals, and vegetables from their greenery enclosures. At the point when the dryness, warmth, and grasshoppers devastated the products, farmers were left with no cash to purchase food or make cultivate installments. A few people lost their farms and moved away. Numerous young fellows took government occupations building streets and scaffolds.

By 1940, typical precipitation returned, and government programs helped cultivate costs and enhance the dirt. About a similar time, another administration program began to attach farmhouses to power, making ranch life less demanding and more secure. In “Rebellion in the Cornbelt”, Mary Heaton Vorse says, “A Farmers’ Holiday association had been organized by one Milo Reno, and the farmers were to refuse to market for thirty days...The Milk Producers’ Association joined forces with the Farmers’ Holiday. All the roads leading to Sioux City were picketed. Trucks by hundreds were turned back. Farmers by hundreds lined the roads. They blockaded the roads with spiked telegraph poles and logs. They took away a sheriffs badge and his badge and threw them in a cornfield. Gallons of milk ran down roadway ditches” (Doc 7).

The Hoover organization had done little to help the farmers. Hoover's "prosperity is just around the corner" more likely than not sounded extremely empty to Midwest farmers. The assault and endeavored lynching of a judge by Iowan farmer in April 1933, prompted the Governor of Iowa to put the state under military law. In May 1933 the Agricultural Adjustment Act (AAA) was passed. This demonstration empowered the individuals who were still left in cultivating to develop less products. Accordingly, there would be less produce available and costs would rise along these lines profiting the farmers. Younger people were jobless and underemployed amid this time, especially if they have not completed high school. Those in the 16-to 24-year-old range who haven't finished secondary school have generally endured more educated. African Americans and other minorities have also always been more vulnerable. As stated in One Third of a Nation, “These young people are growing restive [restless]. Out of some 15 weekly reports from industrial centers all over the country, hardly one omitted a paragraph pointing out that these young people may not tolerate much longer a condition that prevents them from starting normal, acting, self-respecting lives, that will not let them marry and raise families. That condemns them to idleness and want” (Doc 8). To battle this issue, the Roosevelt organization made a special government office devoted helping young people: the National Youth Administration. In general, the NYA helped more than 4.5 million young people look for some kind of employment, get professional training, or bear the cost of a superior instruction before the workplace was shut down in 1943. Similarly imperative, it helped a battling age to keep up its dignity, as well as to add to the development and profitability of the American economy at an edgy time in our history.

Herbert Hoover believed that the administration should act to enhance the economy. The old story of his beliefs in "rugged individualism" has been widely misjudged. Hoover rejected the government helping its citizens but he never grasped the hands-oflaissez-faire mentality. President Herbert Hoover once said, “This is not an issue as to whether the people are going hungry or cold in the United States...It is a question as to whether the American people on the one hand will maintain the spirit of charity and of mutual self help” (Doc 1).

Hoover's approach was definitely not distant. He believed that the American individuals need to show some drive and not look out for the administration to settle it for them. In the meantime he didn't anticipate that the legislature will kick back and let individuals understand it for themselves. The main government association he opposed was immediate national government contribution with people rather individuals. He believed the best possible approach to invigorate the economy was to fortify business and public works through the states. Similarly, Caroline Bird writes, “On her first trip to the mountains, Eleanor Roosevelt saw a little boy trying to hide his pet rabbit…..In West Virginia, miners mobbed company stores demanding food….”No one has starved”, Hoover boasted” (Doc 2). President Hoover’s self reliance attitude, held him back from realizing the terrible conditions millions of people were facing and fixing them. President Roosevelt on the other hand was all about the government helping its citizens. Roosevelt wanted to bring immediate and drastic change to the economy and push Americans out of the depression. Many saw him as a socialist but FDR thought government regulations and aid was absolutely necessary. He created the New Deal program in hopes of providing people with jobs and getting them back on their feet.

Get a custom paper now from our expert writers.

From 1933 until 1941, President Roosevelt's projects and arrangements accomplished all the more than simply modify loan fees, tinker cultivate appropriations and make short term programs. They made a new political coalition that included white working individuals, African Americans and left wing erudite people all working together. Many of the New Deal programs such as Social Security are still in use today. He helped the working class, African Americans, women and young people alike with his economic policies and public initiatives. President Hoover tried to help the people, but he did not have the right mindset. President Roosevelt however, had a completely different political philosophy then President Hoover did, but it worked and helped millions of American families.

Image of Dr. Charlotte Jacobson
This essay was graded by
Dr. Charlotte Jacobson
Essay’s grade:
What’s grading
minus plus
Expert Review
The essay "The Great Depression: Hoover's and Roosevelt's Approaches" presents a well-organized and focused discussion on the different approaches taken by Presidents Hoover and Roosevelt during the Great Depression. The writer demonstrates a good command of sentence structure and grammar, and employs a formal tone throughout the essay. The use of synonyms in place of repetitive words enhances the quality of the essay, and the writer's voice is clear and authoritative. Overall, the essay is well-written and provides a solid analysis of the topic.
minus plus
What can be improved
The essay "The Great Depression: Hoover's and Roosevelt's Approaches" is a well-organized piece that explores the different approaches taken by Presidents Hoover and Roosevelt during the Great Depression. The writer demonstrates a good command of sentence structure and grammar, and employs a formal tone throughout the essay. However, there are some shortcomings in the essay that can be improved upon. One issue is the use of informal language in some parts of the essay. For example, the writer uses the phrase "the same old story" to describe Hoover's approach, which detracts from the formal tone of the essay. This could be corrected by using a more formal phrase, such as "a familiar narrative." Another issue is the lack of in-text citations to support some of the claims made in the essay. For instance, the writer states that "Hoover's reluctance to intervene in the economy... aggravated the crisis," but does not provide any sources to back up this claim. Adding a citation would increase the credibility of the essay and provide more evidence for the argument. Finally, there are a few instances where the writer could have been more specific in their analysis. For example, the essay states that "Roosevelt's policies... aimed to create jobs," but does not provide any details about how these policies achieved that goal. Including specific examples would strengthen the argument and provide more depth to the analysis. In order to improve the quality of the essay, the writer should focus on using more formal language throughout the essay, providing in-text citations to support their arguments, and being more specific in their analysis. Overall, the essay has potential but could benefit from some revisions.

Cite this Essay

The Great Depression: Hoover’s and Roosevelt’s Approaches. (2018, December 03). GradesFixer. Retrieved September 21, 2023, from
“The Great Depression: Hoover’s and Roosevelt’s Approaches.” GradesFixer, 03 Dec. 2018,
The Great Depression: Hoover’s and Roosevelt’s Approaches. [online]. Available at: <> [Accessed 21 Sept. 2023].
The Great Depression: Hoover’s and Roosevelt’s Approaches [Internet]. GradesFixer. 2018 Dec 03 [cited 2023 Sept 21]. Available from:
Keep in mind: This sample was shared by another student.
  • 450+ experts on 30 subjects ready to help
  • Custom essay delivered in as few as 3 hours
Write my essay

Still can’t find what you need?

Browse our vast selection of original essay samples, each expertly formatted and styled


Where do you want us to send this sample?

    By clicking “Continue”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy policy.


    Be careful. This essay is not unique

    This essay was donated by a student and is likely to have been used and submitted before

    Download this Sample

    Free samples may contain mistakes and not unique parts


    Sorry, we could not paraphrase this essay. Our professional writers can rewrite it and get you a unique paper.



    Please check your inbox.

    We can write you a custom essay that will follow your exact instructions and meet the deadlines. Let's fix your grades together!


    Get Your
    Personalized Essay in 3 Hours or Less!


    We can help you get a better grade and deliver your task on time!

    • Instructions Followed To The Letter
    • Deadlines Met At Every Stage
    • Unique And Plagiarism Free
    Order your paper now