Are Prisons Effective in Achieving Their Goals?

Table of Contents

• Deterring Crime
• Rehabilitating Offenders
• Protecting Society
• Conclusion

The whole debate around prisons—whether they really work or not—has been buzzing around for what feels like forever. From lawmakers to academics to just folks on the street, everyone’s got an opinion. Prisons are supposed to stop crime, turn bad guys into good citizens, and keep the rest of us safe by locking up the dangerous ones. But do they actually pull it off? This essay takes a closer look at whether prisons scare off potential criminals, help offenders change their ways, and make our world safer, all while leaning on some solid evidence and real-world stats.

'Are Prisons Effective in Achieving Their Goals?'

Deterring Crime

One big reason people think we need prisons is to scare folks from committing crimes. You know, if you might end up behind bars, maybe you'll think twice about breaking the law. But does it really work that way? Honestly, the evidence is kinda all over the place. A 2016 study by the National Institute of Justice pointed out that knowing you'll likely get caught is a bigger deterrent than the punishment itself. So maybe catching more criminals is better than just throwing longer sentences at them.

Also, Pratt and Cullen did a meta-analysis back in 2005 that showed prison time doesn't do much to stop reoffending. Longer sentences didn’t really cut down on future crimes. Instead, things like community service and probation might be more effective. So, maybe we gotta rethink how we punish people because just relying on prisons doesn't seem to be cutting it.

Rehabilitating Offenders

The other main job of prisons is helping criminals change their ways and fit back into society. Ideally, prisons should offer stuff like education and therapy to make this happen. But reality check—they usually don’t. In 2018, the Bureau of Justice Statistics reported that about 67.8% of released prisoners got rearrested within three years. And within five years? The number shot up to 76.6%. That's a pretty big fail when it comes to rehabilitation.

A bunch of issues are behind this mess-up. Overcrowding's a biggie; many prisons are way over capacity which means limited access to educational programs crucial for rehab. Plus, being in prison can mess with your head—Haney's study from 2001 showed increased anxiety and depression among inmates.

Successful rehab needs a mix of education and support systems. Take Norway’s prisons—they focus more on changing behaviors than just punishment and have recidivism rates around only 20% (Sterbenz, 2014). This proves that with the right setup, helping offenders reform is possible—challenging our usual punitive system.

Protecting Society

The third main goal here is keeping society safe by locking up threats. While this does take some dangerous folks off the streets, it's expensive as heck! According to a report by the Vera Institute of Justice in 2017, it costs about $33,274 a year for just one inmate in the U.S.—a massive strain on taxpayers' wallets.

On top of that, mass incarceration hits marginalized communities hard—it makes social inequalities worse and keeps poverty cycles spinning. A report from The Sentencing Project in 2018 found African Americans are incarcerated at more than five times the rate of whites—a sign there’s something wrong deep within our justice system.

Add to this how former inmates face huge hurdles getting jobs or housing due to stigmatization—leading often back into crime due to limited options available outside prison walls.

Conclusion

So yeah—in terms of scaring off crime or reforming offenders effectively—prisons aren't doing great overall! Evidence suggests other methods could lower crime better than jailing alone would manage; high re-arrest rates show failing attempts at genuine rehabilitation mostly cause overcrowding issues & lack proper resources too often seen inside facilities today worldwide alike!

• Bureau of Justice Statistics (2018)
• The Sentencing Project (2018)
• Sterbenz C., "Norway's Model Prison" (2014)
• Pratt T.C., Cullen F.T., "Meta-Analysis" (2005)
• N.I.J Study (2016)