Conflict with Technology in Coon Tree by E. B. White

Introduction

In E. B. White’s essay “Coon Tree”, White explores the dichotomy between the beauty of nature and the perceived destructiveness of technology. He describes a family of raccoons living in a tree beside his house and shares his frustration with the transformation of his kitchen. Through vivid descriptions, White emphasizes his admiration for nature while expressing his discontent with technological advancements that replace traditional ways.

White's Affection for Nature

White’s affection for the raccoons is evident when he remarks, “She is like a member of our family” (White, 1956, p. 45). Observing the raccoons is a daily ritual for him, akin to his morning shave and evening drink. He knows the raccoon’s schedule intimately, choosing to sacrifice a few ears of corn for the joy of their presence. His dedication is such that he wakes at three in the morning to watch the raccoon return, admiring her silhouette against the sky as she cautiously approaches her home (White, 1956, p. 46). White’s detailed observations reveal his deep connection to the raccoon’s dual nature as both a nurturing mother and a diligent hunter, showcasing his admiration for her instincts and adaptability.

Frustration with Technological Changes

White expresses his frustration with the transformation of his kitchen, believing that while it has evolved, it has lost some of its essence. He reflects on a speaker’s remark that “The kitchen as we know it is a dead dodo,” countering that “I think the kitchen, like the raccoon, is a dead dodo only if you choose to shoot it dead” (White, 1956, p. 48). This statement underscores White’s preference for the familiar and functional aspects of his kitchen, which he sees as a harmonious blend of past, present, and future. He favors traditional appliances, preferring the tactile experience of using a wood stove over the convenience of an electric one.

The Impact of Rapid Technological Advancement

White is concerned about the rapid pace of technological change and its impact on society. He cites Jim Bailey, who says, “I have no sensation of speed when I run,” illustrating how technology evolves almost imperceptibly (Bailey, 1956, p. 50). White argues that technology’s convenience encourages inactivity, contrasting the physical labor once required to gather wood with the simplicity of turning a knob on an electric stove. He fears that such advancements may lead to a loss of appreciation for nature’s intrinsic value and our diminishing physical engagement with the world around us.

Conclusion

In “Coon Tree,” White articulates his conflict with technology, juxtaposing it against the beauty of nature. He perceives the new kitchen as a “dead dodo” due to its increasing ease and reduced need for effort. Through his essay, White provides insightful imagery and reflections, arguing that while nature embodies purity and beauty, technology poses a threat by altering the world and promoting a less active lifestyle. His essay serves as a poignant reminder of the importance of maintaining a balance between embracing technological progress and preserving our connection to the natural world.

References

White, E. B. (1956). Coon Tree. In Essays of E. B. White. Harper & Row.

Bailey, J. (1956). Quoted in White, E. B. Coon Tree. In Essays of E. B. White. Harper & Row.