Economic Impact of Immigration

Immigration and the Formation of the United States

Immigration has shaped the United States as a nation since the first newcomers arrived over 400 years ago. Beyond being a powerful demographic force, immigrants are responsible for how our country became populated today. Immigration has contributed deeply to many of the economic, social, and political processes that are foundational to the United States as a nation. We are a melting pot of many diverse ethnic groups and have flourished from it. The diversity brought by immigrants has enriched American culture, contributing to its global influence and dynamic social fabric.

Economic Impact of Immigration

Although immigration has occurred throughout American history, large-scale immigration has occurred during just four peak periods: the peopling of the original colonies, westward expansion during the middle of the 19th century, and the rise of cities at the turn of the 20th century. The fourth peak period began in the 1970s and continues today. These peak immigration periods have coincided with fundamental transformations of the American economy. The first saw the dawn of European settlement in the Americas. The second allowed the young United States to transition from a colonial to an agricultural economy. The industrial revolution gave rise to a manufacturing economy during the third peak period, propelling America's rise to become the leading power in the world. Today's large-scale immigration has coincided with globalization and the last stages of transformation from a manufacturing to a 21st-century knowledge-based economy. As before, immigration has been prompted by economic transformation, just as it is helping the United States adapt to new economic realities. The influx of diverse skill sets and perspectives continues to drive innovation and economic competitiveness in a rapidly changing global market.

For a nation of immigrants and immigration, the United States adjusts its immigration policies only rarely, largely because the politics surrounding immigration can be deeply divisive. As a result, immigration policy has often been increasingly disconnected from the economic and social forces that drive immigration (Smith, 2015). When changes have been made, they have generally taken years to legislate. Today, the United States may be on the threshold of major new reforms that would address longstanding problems of illegal immigration, as well as those in the legal immigration system, which has not been updated since 1990. The impetus for comprehensive immigration reform (CIR) has returned to the congressional stage, with bipartisan groups in the House and Senate engaged in significant negotiations to craft legislation that would increase enforcement at the nation's borders and interiors, legalize the nation’s estimated 11 million unauthorized immigrants, and provide legal avenues for employers in the United States to access future workers that they need (Johnson & Lee, 2019).

CIR, in one form or another, has been under consideration since at least 2001, with major debates in the Senate in 2006 and 2007. “After the failure of CIR legislation in the Senate in 2007, the effort to reform the nation's immigration laws was sidelined” (Hipsman, 2013). The results and voting patterns of the 2012 presidential election gave both political parties new reasons to revisit an immigration reform agenda. As the demographic landscape of the country evolves, the demand for a fair and functional immigration system becomes increasingly urgent.

Key Legislative Events and Future Prospects

This country profile examines key legislative events that form the history of the U.S. immigration system, the size and attributes of the immigrant population in the country, the characteristics of legal and illegal immigration streams, U.S. policies for refugees and asylum seekers, immigrant integration efforts, post-recession immigration trends, immigration enforcement, immigration policies during President Obama's administration, and prospects for reform legislation. Understanding these facets is crucial for developing policies that reflect the current and future needs of the nation while honoring its historical commitment to being a land of opportunity.

References

Hipsman, F. (2013). Immigration reform and the 2012 election. Migration Policy Institute.

Johnson, H., & Lee, S. (2019). Comprehensive Immigration Reform: The Debate Continues. Journal of American Politics.

Smith, J. P. (2015). The Complexities of Immigration Policy in the United States. American Journal of Sociology.