James Knight vs. Melissa Nelson: An analyzing of events surrounding these cases: [Essay Example], 847 words GradesFixer
exit-popup-close

Haven't found the right essay?

Get an expert to write you the one you need!

exit-popup-print

Professional writers and researchers

exit-popup-quotes

Sources and citation are provided

exit-popup-clock

3 hour delivery

exit-popup-persone
close
This essay has been submitted by a student. This is not an example of the work written by professional essay writers.

James Knight Vs. Melissa Nelson: an Analyzing of Events Surrounding These Cases

Download Print

Pssst… we can write an original essay just for you.

Any subject. Any type of essay.

We’ll even meet a 3-hour deadline.

Get your price

121 writers online

blank-ico
Download PDF

The case concerns the firing of Melissa Nelson, a former employee of James Knight, a dentist. Nelson was hired by Dr. Knight as a dental assistant about 10 years before the events took place and Knight admitted that she was a good dental assistant. A year and a half before Nelson was terminated, Knight began complaining to Nelson that her clothes were too tight and revealing. Around six months before her termination, Nelson and Knight began texting each other, concerning both personal and work related matters. Some texts between the two were suggestive and sexual but Nelson claims she saw Knight as a father figure/friend and didn’t take the texts seriously. Jeanne Knight (Dr. Knight’s wife) was also an employee of Dr. Knight’s practice and found out about the texting and confronted Knight, telling him to terminate Nelson.

The Knight’s consulted a pastor at their church who agreed with the decision to fire Nelson. On January 4, 2010, Knight called Nelson into his office after work and in the presence of a pastor, read from a prepared statement saying that their relationship had become bad for his family, and that it was in both of their best interests for them to stop working together. He then gave her a month’s severance pay and Nelson started crying. Knight met with Nelson’s husband later that evening to let him know that nothing was going on between them but he believed that an affair would result if he hadn’t fired Nelson. Knight replaced Nelson with another female dental assistant.

PROCEDURAL HISTORY

Nelson brought action against Dr. Knight in the Webster County District Court (Iowa) on the basis that Knight discriminated against her on the basis of sex (he wouldn’t have fired her if she was a male) but did not sexually harass her. Knight moved for summary judgment and the District Court sustained the motion in favor of Nelson’s employer, James Knight and she appealed to the Supreme Court of Iowa. The Supreme Court of Iowa affirmed the motion for summary judgment, as Knight’s actions did not amount to unlawful discrimination.

ISSUE

Melissa Nelson claimed that Knight unlawfully discriminated against her by terminating her employment because she was a woman and that he wouldn’t have fired her if she was a man. The issue is whether or not Knight unlawfully discriminated against Nelson. Looking at other cases and the case facts will help to understand the Supreme Court of Iowa’s ruling.

RULES(S)

Unlawful discrimination is the main focus of the case as this is what Nelson specifically alleged that Knight did. Civil rights laws aim to have employees treated the same regardless of gender. The concurring opinion also addresses Employment at Will in that it can conflict with a sharper definition of discrimination because the ability for an employee to be terminated at any time without the employer having to prove a cause is still supported in our society.

APPLICATION/ANALYSIS

Many of the cases mentioned help to differ Nelson’s situation as being completely lawful. Nelson’s responses to Knight’s position are that any discrimination because of the employer’s interest in the employee is discrimination, that there was no employee misconduct requirement, and that Knight shouldn’t be allowed to terminate an employee just because he thought he would sexually harass have an affair with her. Cases such as Bender v. Bellows & Bellows and Blackshear v. Interstate Brands Corp went against Nelson’s view that any termination based on a relationship would be unlawful because termination wouldn’t have happened if the employee was a different gender. Nelson also couldn’t prove unlawful discrimination because there was no pattern of this activity by Knight. Essentially, if Knight had fired multiple women before, it could be argued that he had something against women, but his wife’s objection to Nelson and Knight’s relationship made it clear that it was their relationship and not her gender that motivated the firing. Gender stereotypes are important and were a key factor in Lewis v. Heartland Inns of America where Lewis was fired from her motel desk job for not looking like a Midwestern girl. This case is based solely on stereotypes, which are not conducive to equal employment, and not a relationship between employer and employee. There is no stereotyping in Nelson v. Knight and the termination is based on the two’s relationship. Nelson’s third point is that Knight can’t fire her because he thought he might harass her in the future but her termination did not bring any of the hostility associated with sexual harassment and would not be considered unlawful even if it was unfair.

CONCLUSION

Nelson was in the wrong in this case because she couldn’t prove any of the normal features of unlawful discrimination. Even though her termination may have been unfair, it is still legal because Knight didn’t have any reason to fire her based on her gender. The termination was brought about by his wife’s objection to the relationship, not to Nelson’s gender. Nelson’s three responses to Knight’s position have many flaws demonstrated through other cases.

infoRemember: This is just a sample from a fellow student.

Your time is important. Let us write you an essay from scratch

100% plagiarism-free

Sources and citations are provided

Find Free Essays

We provide you with original essay samples, perfect formatting and styling

Cite this Essay

To export a reference to this article please select a referencing style below:

James Knight vs. Melissa Nelson: An analyzing of events surrounding these cases. (2018, December 11). GradesFixer. Retrieved February 27, 2021, from https://gradesfixer.com/free-essay-examples/james-knight-vs-melissa-nelson-an-analyzing-of-events-surrounding-these-cases/
“James Knight vs. Melissa Nelson: An analyzing of events surrounding these cases.” GradesFixer, 11 Dec. 2018, gradesfixer.com/free-essay-examples/james-knight-vs-melissa-nelson-an-analyzing-of-events-surrounding-these-cases/
James Knight vs. Melissa Nelson: An analyzing of events surrounding these cases. [online]. Available at: <https://gradesfixer.com/free-essay-examples/james-knight-vs-melissa-nelson-an-analyzing-of-events-surrounding-these-cases/> [Accessed 27 Feb. 2021].
James Knight vs. Melissa Nelson: An analyzing of events surrounding these cases [Internet]. GradesFixer. 2018 Dec 11 [cited 2021 Feb 27]. Available from: https://gradesfixer.com/free-essay-examples/james-knight-vs-melissa-nelson-an-analyzing-of-events-surrounding-these-cases/
copy to clipboard
close

Sorry, copying is not allowed on our website. If you’d like this or any other sample, we’ll happily email it to you.

    By clicking “Send”, you agree to our Terms of service and Privacy statement. We will occasionally send you account related emails.

    close

    Attention! this essay is not unique. You can get 100% plagiarism FREE essay in 30sec

    Recieve 100% plagiarism-Free paper just for 4.99$ on email
    get unique paper
    *Public papers are open and may contain not unique content
    download public sample
    close

    Sorry, we cannot unicalize this essay. You can order Unique paper and our professionals Rewrite it for you

    close

    Thanks!

    Your essay sample has been sent.

    Want us to write one just for you? We can custom edit this essay into an original, 100% plagiarism free essay.

    thanks-icon Order now
    boy

    Hi there!

    Are you interested in getting a customized paper?

    Check it out!
    Having trouble finding the perfect essay? We’ve got you covered. Hire a writer

    GradesFixer.com uses cookies. By continuing we’ll assume you board with our cookie policy.